‘It’s been a hard year’: Hallie Scruggs family reflects on year without her

One year ago, three adults and three children were killed at Covenant Presbyterian School.
Kara Arnold, Scruggs’ aunt, said she was close with her brothers and cousins.
By Danica Sauter and Joylyn Bukovac Published: Mar. 27, 2024 at 6:34 AM CDT|Updated: Mar. 27, 2024 at 7:20 AM CDTEmail This LinkShare on FacebookShare on X (formerly Twitter)Share on PinterestShare on LinkedIn

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WSMV) - March 27, 2023, is a day Nashvillians will never forget.

One year ago, six people were killed at Covenant Presbyterian School including three students and three adults.

‘Your kindness has been a beacon of hope’: Covenant School marks 1 year since deadly shooting with gratitude

The families of Evelyn Dieckhaus, Hallie Scruggs, William Kinney, Cynthia Peak, Katherine Koonce, and Mike Hill are still working through the trauma and grief while keeping the victim’s memories alive.

The victims of the Covenant School shooting in Nashville on March 27, 2023.
The victims of the Covenant School shooting in Nashville on March 27, 2023.(WSMV)

One of the families who will never forget this day is the family of Scruggs.

Kara Arnold, Scruggs’ aunt, said she was close with her brothers and cousins. Even though she was outnumbered by boys, she could still keep up with them.

Covenant School launches ‘1,000 Thank Yous’ campaign months after mass shooting

“She was always just in the center of it. You just couldn’t. There was nothing she couldn’t do,” Arnold said. “She was never going to be who you thought she should be or who you wanted her to be or anything like that. She was just true to who she was and fashioned in the way she moved through life. It was really just beautiful.”

After a year of birthdays and holidays, Scruggs’ family is clinging on to the memories they made of her saying that during hard times like this, that’s what gets them through.

“It’s been a hard year for sure,” Arnold said. “But learning to hold grief and joy at the same time, all the time.”

Arnold said that Chip, one of her sons and one of the cousins closest to Scruggs, sometimes catches her crying.

“He had to just come in and start telling me happy stories about her, you know…He knows that this is sad and this is hard,” Arnold said.

Arnold said that even though it’s hard to cope with the loss of Scruggs, there is so much good and that she and her family won’t let go of that.

“There’s so much happiness when we think of her and that’s what we want to share with people,” Arnold said. “We want to hold on to that really deeply.”

‘I’m a lot stronger’: Covenant School father reflects 7 months after deadly shooting

Arnold said if she could tell Scruggs anything she would tell her the following:

“Thank you for the example that you set. She is now the bar for my boys for every girl they’ll come in contact with for the rest of their lives. And just being so true to herself that was such an example. She touched so many people because of that. Thank you for doing that [and] for being who she was to her very, very core. She always was.”

A little more than two years ago, Arnold and her family moved from Nashville to Colorado to buy a motel.

“Our community is so amazing out there, but we really just wanted people to know her because everyone knows her here in Nashville, but in Colorado they don’t,” Arnold said. “We just want to talk about her and share our memories and we want people to ask about her.”

One way the Arnold family is holding on to Scruggs’ memory is by building a memorial garden. Arnold revealed the motel was donated a tree from a local company in Canyon City.

“We’re trying to build a memorial garden around it just so that we can share her with everyone who comes out,” Arnold said.

A month after the tragic shooting, in April 2023, the Community Foundation of Middle Tennessee created a fund in Scruggs’ memory and to honor the memory of other children whose lives have been cut short because of school violence.

The Covenant Presbyterian School released a statement regarding the last year:

The past year has been terribly difficult for our community, and the pain is still very real. Throughout this challenging time, our unwavering commitment has been to prioritize the well-being and healing of our students, families, teachers and staff. As we mark this painful anniversary, we find solace in the light that has emerged from the darkness. It is with profound gratitude that we acknowledge the overwhelming outpouring of love and support we have received from our local Nashville community and around the world. Your kindness has been a beacon of hope, and the depth of your generosity profoundly moves us. We continue to see all of the ways in which the Lord is providing for and loving our community. He has been and will continue to be our comfort and strength.”

Most Read

Humphreys County schools director ‘consummated’ romantic relationship with teacher in his...
Humphreys County schools director ‘consummated’ romantic relationship with teacher in his office, investigator finds
3 dead after plane crashes in Williamson County, officials say
3 dead after plane crashes in Williamson County, officials say
Police are looking for a man who allegedly took photos of an 11-year-old boy using the bathroom.
Suspect identified after taking photos of boy inside mall bathroom, police say
Asher Sullivan
Family praying for improvement to boy’s brain after suffering severe damage from being swept into storm drain
Police are investigating a shooting at a 7-Eleven off Joe B. Jackson Parkway.
2 shot, 2 in custody after Murfreesboro 7-Eleven shooting

Latest News

For the first time since the night they lost their daughter in the Putnam County tornadoes, a...
Foundation honors daughter killed in tornado
Rutherford Co Sheriffs deputies save bird
Deputies save bird from storms in Rutherford County
Headstones ran over after vehicle vandalizes Tennessee cemetery
Headstones ran over after vehicle vandalizes Tennessee cemetery
Tennessee Promise scholarship extended to end of May due to FAFSA issues
People in an Ashland City neighborhood woke up to find a large rockslide covering their road...
Rockslide blocks road to Ashland City